Start with what you already own
If the boat has a radar, autopilot or sonar module from one brand, staying with that brand is usually the simplest and cheapest path, because those pieces talk to the new display without adapters. Mixing brands is possible over NMEA 2000, but radar and sonar modules are mostly brand-specific.
Decide what the screen is for
- Inshore fishing: side-scan and down-scan sonar quality matters most. Look at the sonar modules each brand pairs with its displays.
- Offshore fishing: a strong CHIRP sonar for depth, good radar integration and a screen you can read at noon.
- Cruising and the Intracoastal: chart detail, auto-routing and how the display handles the autopilot.
- A family boat: simple menus, a touchscreen that works with wet hands, and phone integration.
Charts
Each brand has its own chart products and the detail on your local water varies. Ask to see the chart of your own inlet or your own creek on each one before you buy. It is a small thing that you will look at every trip.
Size and the helm
Bigger is better until it does not fit. Measure the dash, account for the gauges and switches that have to stay, and remember that two medium screens often beat one large one, because you can run the chart and the sonar full-size at the same time.
A new display in an old dash often means a new panel. That is normal and is usually the moment to clean up the switches and the old holes too.
Questions people ask next
What size chartplotter should I get?
The biggest that fits the dash with the gauges and switches that have to stay. Measure first. Two medium screens often beat one large one, because the chart and the sonar can both run full size at the same time.
Can I use a different brand of sonar with my chartplotter?
Mostly no. Displays share GPS and engine data over NMEA 2000, but sonar and radar modules are built for their own brand of display. If you want to keep an existing sonar or radar, stay with that brand for the new screen.
Do I need new charts when I buy a new chartplotter?
Usually the display ships with a base chart, and the detailed chart for your own water is a separate card or download. Look at the chart of your own inlet on each brand before you buy; the detail on local water varies more than people expect.